.
Feedback

D87 Board Member: P.E. Waiver Keeps Students Competitive With Top High Schools

The following is a letter to the editor provided by Glenbard Township High School District 87 Board Member Mary Ozog.

 

Right when school started this year a concerned parent posted the following petition:

http://www.gopetition.com/petitions/allow-pe-waivers-again-in-glenbard-school-district-87.html


Since that time, almost 400 parents throughout the district have signed this petition requesting that District 87 continue to allow this waiver from P.E. classes. The administration does not mention that without this waiver music and other elective programs such as foreign language, art, business, and industrial arts programs throughout the district will probably suffer a loss of enrollment since students cannot participate in these areas and fulfill the new graduation requirements of District 87.

For example, without this waiver it will no longer be possible to take four years of Band, Orchestra, or Choir and four years of foreign language without summer school or P.E. at 6:45 am. Summer school and P.E. at 6:45 am are solutions presented by the administration. I believe that both of these options are problematic for students, and requiring summer school to complete requirements in order to stay enrolled in music and other electives, in particular, cuts into opportunities for summer employment, required athletic and music camps, and also is discriminatory toward those families who do make too much money to qualify for summer school tuition waivers, but for whom an additional $200-300 in summer school fees would prove a definite hardship.

With a waiver, athletes who receive a study hall during their season are able to spend that period on their studies. This is especially important when these athletes are spending often three hours after school at practice alone. Add in travel time to away activities and this period becomes even more important.

I have done a seat of the pants analysis of which comparable high schools offer this waiver opportunity, and have found that virtually ALL DuPage County public schools allow this waiver for their students. Highly ranked schools outside DuPage allowing the waiver include New Trier, Highland Park, the Deerfield Schools, and the Glenbrook Schools, as well as the most highly ranked schools in the state: the prep schools of the Chicago Public School district (Northside Prep, Walter Payton, et. al.) allow a P.E. waiver for the reasons listed in the petition.

Finally, the four year P.E. requirement for high school students in the State of Illinois has existed since sometime after World War II. Only Illinois (of all 50 states) requires four years of P.E. in high school. Yet, even with this requirement in place, obesity rates have skyrocketed across ALL levels of the population over the last 15 years, or so. While I am, of course, in favor of physical education for all students, clearly not re-applying for this waiver at the state level is throwing the baby out with the bath water.

Tonight, I will urge the Board to vote in favor of renewing the waiver for Junior and Senior students in District 87. We need this waiver to meet the needs of our students and to stay competitive with the best-ranked high schools in the area, and the state.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Glen Ellyn Patch? Find your Local Patch »

Susan Klimala January 9, 2012 at 05:42 pm
I do not understand why P.E. is a requirement if your child is already enrolled in one or more high school sports. What is the argument for P.E. in these instances? This seems like an easy call. What is the obstacle?
John Glavin January 12, 2012 at 04:28 pm
I follow the logic in allowing those playing sports for their school to skip P.E. exclusively during the sports season. However, I don't follow why you would only apply it to juniors and seniors. We have varsity athletes among the freshman & sophmores who would equally benefit from this exemption, and well as many athletes on the freshmen/J.V. teams who would benefit as well.
I also am confused by the overall vision of the GBW administration on this topic. They are arguing for lights at Memorial Field so GBW can safety hold more practice time & their equitable share of matches. With this increased capacity of capturing the students' after school hours time, the need for this study hall exception increases as well - doesn't it?
Dave Pena March 8, 2012 at 04:53 pm
The argument is pretty simple. Physical Education at the high school level is to educate the students on wellness. Exemptions should be done away with because quite frankly there is nothing more important than one's health and wellness. PE isn't dodgeball and rolling out the balls anymore. If that's what your teachers are doing they need to be reprimanded and replaced if they don't start teaching.
I would never allow one of my children to exempt out. One of my daughters runs cross country and track in high school. She's in great shape. But what is she learning about wellness in those sports? Not much. She can't tell me that when she's training that her heart rate must be at 185 bpm and remain in that performance zone for a sustained amount of time to achieve maximum results. Is she burning fat calories as well as calories from other sources and if so what percentages? What is Interval training doing for her? Why? What are the benifits of being in the fat burning and endurance training zones? Disadvantages? I'm sorry but her coaches pushing her to workout is a big difference from her being taught what's happening in her body are two totally different things.
Susan Klimala September 9, 2012 at 01:35 am
If a student is in one or more sports, they are getting a pretty good education quickly about wellness. If a kid is playing high school sports, they are likely interested enough to soak up the information needed for a lifetime of wellness. If a child playing a HS sport(s) has difficulty fitting in a course like Anatomy/Biology to accommodate P.E. this seems off target. It just seems like common sense.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something